How did judas die by hanging or falling down And the acts of the apostles show this, that falling head long he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out. Whether it was suicide as per Matthew 27, or a gruesome accident as per Acts 1:18, the exact circumstances of Judas’ death are shrouded in mystery. Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed, and went and hanged himself. ” So how did Judas die? Posted by u/TonyChanYT - 2 votes and no comments So, what happened here is that Judas went and hung himself and then his body later fell down and split open. The two passages are not mutually exclusive. After Judas hung himself his body could have been left for some time and began the process of decom position. Jul 1, 2013 · Judas did not go down head first but fell down on his face. According to the Gospel of Matthew, Judas hanged himself after betraying Jesus to the authorities. The tree branch could have broken. The question surrounding Judas’s death arises from what appears to be two different biblical accounts found in Matthew 27:3-10 and Acts 1:18-19. He owned the field. This event led to Jesus’ arrest and subsequent crucifixion. After some of the Temple priests converted (cf. As Jesus's disciples discussed replacing Judas as the 12th disciple following his death, Peter reminds them in Acts 1:15–20 of what happened to Judas. Judas died by hanging himself. So Judas’ “fall” may naturally be explained as the result of the rope—or the branch of the tree—breaking (or Oct 15, 2024 · Matthew and Luke do not negate nor contradict each other on Judas’ death. May 17, 2019 · The reconciliation is that he hung himself before falling to the ground. For example, if I saw a car hit a pedestrian, I might simply say that the pedestrian died because he was hit by the car. Rope didn't have to break. . The other a bit later on (in those climates) where the corpse is so decayed that it breaks apart under its own weight and hits the floor, bursting apart. This is Mar 7, 2025 · Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5), or did he die by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? The relevant passages state: Matthew 27:5 – “Then Judas threw the silver coins down in the Temple and went out and hanged himself. The death of history’s most infamous traitor has stirred up such postmortem word-of-mouth controversy that it could be considered the classic Bible contradiction – the crême de Matthew 27:5 said of Judas after he betrayed Jesus, “Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed and went and hanged himself. Now, let’s dive into the details! Did Judas Hang Himself Or Fall So according to Matthew 27:3–10, Judas hanged himself. However, when we read Acts 1:18 Peter says something different: “…he fell headlong, his body burst open and all his intestines spilled out. If we maintain that Judas' body was removed from its position before stage 2 of decomposition (Deut 21:23; Num. Peter says that Judas kept the money, and used it to buy a field. Judas probably began accompanying Jesus while in his twenties (Jesus began his ministry when about thirty; Luke Jan 20, 2019 · Peter’s words, as recorded by Luke in the Book of Acts, are not in referring to the way in which Judas died, Judas did not die this way, nor is Peter referring to what happened to the body of Judas after he died, rather Peter is demonstrating the inner anguish with which Judas was beset after he had betrayed Jesus and his falling away from Judas Didn't Hang Himself--He Died from a Fall In those days Peter stood up among the believers (a group numbering about a hundred and twenty) and said, "Brothers, the Scripture had to be fulfilled which the Holy Spirit spoke long ago through the mouth of David concerning Judas, who served as guide for those who arrested Jesus--he was one of Mar 22, 2011 · Did Judas die by hanging himself, or by falling over in a field and having his midsection burst open spilling his guts everywhere? A. Mark 14:10-11 Then Judas Iscariot, one of the Twelve, went to the chief priests to betray Jesus to them. falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his intestines gushed out. Matthew tells us the priests purchased a field with 30 pieces of silver, Acts tells us the purchase price was the “reward of iniquity” paid for by Judas. However, the Book of Acts records a different version of Judas's death. And it became known to all who were living in Jerusalem; so that in their own language that field was called Hakeldama, that is, Field of Blood. 2. Acts 1:18-19 Question _: Did Judas die by hanging or by falling on rocks? (Matthew 27:5, Acts 1:18) Answer:_ Both accounts are accurate descriptions of the same event. The most likely explanation is that Judas died when he hanged himself (Matthew 27:3-8), and then sometime after this, Judas fell into the field that he had acquired (Acts 1:16-19). ” However, Acts 1:18 recorded that Judas “purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling I also include his response to another specific aspect related to the story of Judas. Immediate Cause (Hanging): Matthew focuses on Judas’s decision to hang himself, emphasizing the immediate cause of death-Judas’s intentional act in a moment of despair. Judas did not die by hanging, but he survived after being taken down, before he had choked to death. According to the Gospel of Matthew, Judas hanged himself after betraying Jesus to the authorities. Judas Iscariot committed suicide. Problem: Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5) or did he die by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? Solution: The relevant passages are: Matthew 27:5 Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed, and went and hanged himself. He hung himself, presumably from a tree, in a potter’s field. Jan 4, 2022 · Note that Luke does not say that Judas died from the fall, only that his body fell. However, the solution to this alleged contradiction in the Bible is simple. Luke writes in Acts 1:18 “Now this man purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his entrails gushed out” Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5) or did he perish by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? Let’s see what the exegetical evidence will reveal. Oct 5, 2023 · Note that Luke does not say that Judas died from the fall, only that his body fell. That Judas hung himself at night but the branch broke and he was decapitated in his fall. Then I mentioned for people to see my primary comment on here which explains this subject. Think on this: if Judas hung himself, and the rope is hanging around his neck and swinging, then the motion of the rope and the force around his neck could have caused the rope to break and Judas to plunge “head Falling headlong. ” Judas hung himself exactly as Matthew affirms that he did. Jun 7, 2023 · Conclusion – The Enigma Remains. ” 18 (Now this man purchased a field with the wages of iniquity; and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his May 25, 2009 · Since the Bible is inerrant Judas cannot have died by hanging and died by falling and bursting open. And it was known unto all the dwellers at Jerusalem; insomuch as that field is called in their proper tongue, Aceldama, that is to say, The field of blood. Now, while this deduction is by all means correct, this stands behind the translation of prenes as swollen/burst in the Vulgate, which means the tradition that led to this never described Judas' death by a fall from a high place, and Luke did indeed mean that Judas died from a (short) fall, "becoming prostrate", and this certainly due to having Did Judas Iscariot, after betraying Christ, hang himself or just swell up and burst open? We should first understand that God had His Word recorded in such a way that it could be misunderstood. This is the very thing one would expect of someone who hanged himself from a tree over a cliff and fell on sharp rocks below. ACTS 1:16-19 16 “Men and brethren, this Scripture had to be fulfilled, which the Holy Spirit spoke before by the mouth of David concerning Judas, who became a guide to those who arrested Jesus; 17 for he was numbered with us and obtained a part in this ministry. So they bound him, led him away and handed him over to Pilate the governor. You've got two images from different points in the hanging process. It is likely that Judas hung himself from a tree and after his body began to decompose, either the tree limb broke or someone cut the branch from which he was hanging down to remove his body, causing Judas to fall to the ground. Both agree Judas died shortly after the Crucifixion. / They were delighted to hear this, and they promised to give him money. His body went unburied because it was Passover. So rather than telling everyone that Judas had died (or how he died), Peter might be adding some information about an event that happened post mortem. Jun 25, 2018 · I want to discuss this particular contradiction claimed in bible. Matthew describes Judas as hanging himself in a tree after his betrayal of Jesus. DEFENSE: The accounts preserve different aspects of the event but do not contradict each other. It isn't really important exactly how he died; Luke includes it in Acts in connection with the need to replace him. You see to it!" Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed, and went and hanged himself. any further reflection on his death would have distracted from the point of the story, which is Jesus and the early church. Otherwise, if forced to acknowledge the two obviously different accounts in Matthew’s Gospel and Acts of the Apostles, the first step should be to “salami-slice” off the disposition of the reward money—did Judas throw the money back in the temple or did he buy land with it—so that there is only one major contradiction Mar 31, 2025 · CHALLENGE: Matthew and Luke contradict each other. Absalom’s death is unusual. The Acts of the Apostles signifies this as well: 'Falling headfirst he burst forth in the middle, and his intestines became exposed/poured out. He hanged himself. Matthew does not say Judas did not fall and Acts does not say that Judas did not hang himself. Some critics of the Bible see this difference in the description of Judas death as a discrepancy that casts doubt on the reliability of the New Testament. ” Mar 10, 2010 · When Peter spoke before the other apostles, it might have already been understood by all that Judas had already died. Now, Judas did hang himself, but he also burst open after death. / So from then on Judas looked for an opportunity to betray Jesus. May 12, 2023 · The **Bible **provides two accounts of Judas's death. ” The usual strategy is to harmonize the two stories. How did Judas die, and who bought the potter's field? I believe with all my heart that the Bible is absolutely true in everything it says. I think that if one writer had him dying by hanging himself and the other explicitly stating he died by some other means, and there was no way that both could be true, then you would have a serious issue. Matthew 27:5 said of Judas after he betrayed Jesus, “Then he threw down the pieces of silver in the temple and departed and went and hanged himself. “I have Mar 29, 2024 · How Did Judas REALLY Die? It seems like the Gospels are fighting over how Judas died, and so are we. But what about the manner of Judas’ death? Did he stumble to his death on that field or go off somewhere and hang himself? This aspect of the accounts can be reconciled if you know something about human anatomy and post-mortem bloating. As mentioned above, a body falling from a tree will not likely “burst open. Oct 8, 2024 · In Acts 1:18, Luke says, “Now this man acquired a field with the price of his wickedness, and falling headlong, he burst open in the middle and all his intestines gushed out. xkv gsiw oao mugk hjpzmk ijbqtie xgknmj fxka qpjee yudg rbwt dvx jbylhj facjwv hwoy